Styx (formed 1972, Chicago) is a top-tier classic rock act but not typically ranked in the "greatest of all time" elite (Beatles, Stones, Zeppelin, Pink Floyd, Queen, Who).
Praised for musicianship (Tommy Shaw, James "JY" Young, Dennis DeYoung, Chuck Panozzo, John Panozzo), harmonic sophistication, and theatrical concept albums. Criticized by some for "corporate rock" polish and DeYoung/Shaw feuds.
Top 30–40 all-time by commercial impact & longevity. A "second-tier legend" — immensely successful, culturally embedded, but not genre-defining like the Mount Rushmore bands.