The 1995 TV-horror film **The Babysitter** (dir. Jeffrey Reiner, starring Alicia Silverstone) matches your beats:
Earlier (1979) and later (2017) films share the “babysitter + calls” trope (*When a Stranger Calls*, *The Babysitter* Netflix), but the **1995 Silverstone vehicle** most cleanly fits “killer hiding in the house throughout.”