You’re describing The Bad Seed (1956), adapted from William March’s novel. Rhoda “Bonnie” Penmark (Patty McCormack) presents as a perfect child but coldly murders classmates and her younger brother. Her father, Colonel Kenneth Penmark (William Hopper), uncovers the truth in a devastating climax. Themes: nature vs. nurture, the “triple helix” of evil, and the horror of innocence corrupted.