No official, consistent "highest score" exists because Miss Universe scoring systems have changed repeatedly (1952–present):
Commonly Cited Claim: Mpule Kwelagobe (Botswana, Miss Universe 1999) allegedly scored 997.5/1000 — but this is unverified; the 1999 pageant used a ranking system, not point totals.
Modern pageants (post-2015) emphasize advocacy, impact, interview over numerical scoring. Transparency is limited; "highest score" is largely apocryphal.