Season 2 (2003): Ruben Studdard (defeated Clay Aiken).
Season 3 (2004): Fantasia Barrino (defeated Diana DeGarmo).
Subsequent winners: Carrie Underwood (S4), Taylor Hicks (S5), Jordin Sparks (S6), David Cook (S7), Kris Allen (S8), Lee DeWyze (S9), Scotty McCreery (S10), Phillip Phillips (S11), Candice Glover (S12), Caleb Johnson (S13), Nick Fradiani (S14), Trent Harmon (S15), Maddie Poppe (S16), Laine Hardy (S17), Just Sam (S18), Chayce Beckham (S19), Noah Thompson (S20), Iam Tongi (S21), Abi Carter (S22).