- 2010: Best Rock or Rap Gospel Album (Comatose)
- 2012: Best Rock or Rap Gospel Album (Awake)
- 2019: Best Contemporary Christian Music Performance/Song ("Victorious")
Dove Awards:
- 2004: Rock Album of the Year (Collide)
- 2007: Rock Album of the Year (Comatose)
- 2009: Rock Song of the Year ("Monster")
- 2010: Rock Album of the Year (Awake)
- 2012: Rock Song of the Year ("Sick of It")
- 2014: Rock Album of the Year (Rise)
- 2016: Rock Song of the Year ("Not Gonna Die")
- 2019: Rock/Contemporary Recorded Song of the Year ("Feel Invincible")
K-LOVE Fan Awards:
- 2008: Group/Duo of the Year
- 2010: Group/Duo of the Year
- 2012: Group/Duo of the Year
- 2014: Group/Duo of the Year
- 2016: Group/Duo of the Year
- 2018: Group/Duo of the Year
Billboard Music Awards:
- 2011: Top Christian Album (Awake)
- 2012: Top Christian Artist
- 2013: Top Christian Album (Rise)
- 2014: Top Christian Artist
- 2016: Top Christian Artist
American Music Awards:
- 2016: Favorite Artist - Contemporary Inspirational