* 1999: Best Featured Actress in a Musical (for _You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown_)
* 2003: Best Leading Actress in a Musical (for _Wicked_)
* Grammy Awards:
* 1999: Best Musical Show Album (for _You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown_)
* 2004: Best Musical Show Album (for _Wicked_)
* Emmy Awards:
* 2009: Outstanding Individual Performance in a Variety or Music Program (for _Pushing Daisies_)
* Golden Globe Awards:
* 2010: Best Supporting Actress – Series, Miniseries or Motion Picture Made for Television (for _Pushing Daisies_)
* Screen Actors Guild Awards:
* 2009: Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Comedy Series (for _Pushing Daisies_)