Television:
* "The Good Place" (2016-2020): He plays the recurring role of "Chidi Anagonye", a philosophy professor who is one of the main characters in the series. This is Holloway's most prominent role, gaining him critical acclaim and a wider audience.
* "Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt" (2015-2019): He has a guest role in this acclaimed comedy series, showcasing his comedic timing.
* "Brooklyn Nine-Nine" (2017): Holloway had a guest role in this popular police comedy.
* "Search Party" (2016-2017): He appeared in this dark comedy-mystery series.
* "Difficult People" (2015-2017): He has a guest role in this satirical comedy series.
* "Modern Family" (2017): Holloway guest-starred in this sitcom.
* "The Afterparty" (2022): He has a recurring role in this mystery-comedy series.
Film:
* "The Land of Steady Habits" (2018): This is one of Holloway's few film credits, where he had a small role.
* "The Tomorrow War" (2021): He played a supporting character in this science fiction action film.
While his film appearances are limited, Holloway's work in television has made him a recognizable and respected actor. His talent and comedic skills continue to garner him opportunities in the industry.