Gandalf's Evolving Feelings Toward Bilbo Baggins
Gandalf's view of Bilbo transforms across The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings—from skepticism to deep affection and respect.
Initially (The Hobbit)
- Skeptical: Sees Bilbo as a "comfortable hobbit" with no adventure in him—surprising choice for burglar.
- Intrigued: Notices latent Tookish spirit—Bilbo's unexpected bravery in the Troll Cave and riddle-game with Gollum.
- Respectful: Acknowledges Bilbo's resourcefulness and courage despite his self-doubt and complaints.
During the Quest
- Appreciative: Recognizes Bilbo as the key to the quest's success—the Arkenstone discovery, Smaug's weak spot, diplomatic efforts.
- Proud: Admires Bilbo's growth from baggage to essential companion.
- Concerned: Worries about the Ring's influence and the physical/emotional toll on a small hobbit.
Ultimately (The Lord of the Rings)
- Affectionate: Dear friend, deeply respected for his role in the greater good.
- Protective: Understands the Ring's burden; arranges Bilbo's retirement to Rivendell.
- Grateful: Sees Bilbo's mercy toward Gollaw as pivotal to the Ring's destruction.
Arc: Skepticism → Intrigue → Respect → Appreciation → Pride → Concern → Deep Affection. Gandalf saw potential where others saw only a grocer—and was proven right.