In Yu-Gi-Oh!, the interaction between Monarch monsters and summon negation is a frequent source of confusion. The ruling hinges entirely on the type of effect the Monarch possesses. Understanding this distinction is essential for competitive play.
A Continuous Effect is one that remains active as long as the monster is face-up on the field (e.g., "All opponent's monsters lose 500 ATK"). If the Monarch's summon is negated (by Solemn Judgment, Solemn Warning, Forbidden Droplet, etc.), the monster never successfully enters the field. Consequently, its Continuous Effect never applies. Older card texts and community debates caused confusion, but modern Master Rules and official Konami rulings are unambiguous: a negated summon means the monster was never on the field, so continuous effects cannot function.
Triggered Effects activate "when... you can" or "if... you can" upon a specific event—here, a successful summon. If the summon is negated, the trigger condition ("when this card is summoned") is never met. The effect cannot activate. This applies to Monarchs like Caius the Shadow Monarch (banish a card) or Mobius the Frost Monarch (destroy spell/traps).
Erebus has a Continuous Effect that negates opponent's monster effects. If its summon is negated, Erebus never reaches the field, so its negation effect does not apply. (Note: Earlier community answers incorrectly stated continuous effects persist; current official rulings confirm they do not.)
Caius has a Triggered Effect to banish one card on the field. If its summon is negated by Solemn Warning, the effect cannot activate because the summon wasn't successful.
Negated Summon = Monster Never Existed on the Field. Therefore:
Always verify card text against the current Master Rules and official Konami rulings, as older cards may have outdated wording that suggests otherwise.