How Dumbledore Won the Elder Wand: By Disarming Grindelwald, Not Dueling for It
Dumbledore did not duel for it. Sequence:
- Gregorovitch (wandmaker) owned it.
- Grindelwald stole it (stunning Gregorovitch).
- Dumbledore defeated Grindelwald in a legendary duel (1945) but did not take the wand—Grindelwald was imprisoned with it.
- Decades later, Dumbledore visited Gregorovitch, deduced Grindelwald was master, located him in Nurmengard, and disarmed him—winning allegiance without killing.
The Elder Wand transfers only when its current master is defeated/disarmed.