Losing Rock Smash in Pokémon Gold: Consequences and Workarounds
In Pokémon Gold (and Silver/Crystal), Rock Smash is a crucial HM (TM08 in Gen II) that clears broken rocks blocking paths. Losing access to it—whether by overwriting the move, boxing the only Pokémon that knows it, or restarting without a Rock Smash user—creates significant hurdles.
Major Problems
- Blocked progression – Key routes become impassable: Ilex Forest (access to Azalea Gym), Radio Tower entrance (Goldenrod), and Ice Path (route to Blackthorn City).
- Missed items – Hidden TMs, Rare Candies, evolution stones, and other pickups behind smashable rocks are permanently inaccessible.
- Onix evolution blocked – Onix requires Metal Coat + trade, but in Gen II, you also need Rock Smash to reach certain areas where Metal Coat or high-level Onix appear.
- Rock-type disadvantage – Without Rock Smash’s Fighting-type coverage, battles against Rock/Steel gym leaders (Bugsy’s Scyther, Whitney’s Miltank indirectly, Pryce’s Piloswine) become harder.
- Limited exploration – Post-game areas like Mt. Silver and the Ruins of Alph have rock obstacles.
Practical Solutions
- Trade for a Rock Smash user – The most reliable fix. Ask a friend to send a Pokémon (e.g., Geodude, Machop, Heracross) that knows the move.
- Find the TM – Rock Smash TM is obtainable once (from a hiker in Route 36 after beating Faulkner). If you used it already, it’s gone unless you trade for another.
- Use Strength for boulders – Strength (HM04) moves large boulders but not the small cracked rocks that require Rock Smash.
- Alternate routes – Some areas have roundabout paths (e.g., entering Ilex Forest from the north via Route 34), but they’re longer and may require other HMs.
- Adapt your team – Teach Fighting-type moves (Dynamic Punch, Cross Chop) via TMs/breeding to cover Rock/Steel weaknesses.
Bottom line: Losing Rock Smash is a major setback but not game-breaking. Resourcefulness—trading, backtracking, or adjusting your moveset—will get you through Johto.