Arts >> Magic >> Magic Tricks

How Bilbo Solved the Secret Door Riddle in The Hobbit

In Chapter 1, Bilbo opens the hidden door to the trolls' cave not by a spoken riddle, but by observation and quick thinking:

  1. He notices a keyhole and a round knob on a seemingly blank stone wall.
  2. He asks the trolls (who are arguing nearby), "Is it safe to go through that door, or are there nasty things behind it?"
  3. The dim-witted trolls reply it's safe — "nothing nasty behind it, only nasty things outside."
  4. Bilbo realizes the "riddle" is literal: "It's safe to go through this door, but dangerous to stay outside." He speaks this, and the door opens.

His curiosity, willingness to question, and lateral thinking solve it — not a traditional riddle-game.

Magic Tricks

Related Categories