Here's why:
* Different Generations: Pokémon Pearl is a fourth-generation game (Diamond, Pearl, and Platinum), while Pokémon Emerald is a third-generation game (Ruby, Sapphire, and Emerald).
* Data Incompatibility: The save data formats and game mechanics are different between the two generations.
You can only transfer Pokémon from a third-generation game to a fourth-generation game using a specific method:
1. Pal Park: In Pokémon Diamond, Pearl, and Platinum, there is a location called Pal Park.
2. Transferring: You can transfer Pokémon from your Emerald save file to Pal Park using a special cable called the Nintendo DS Wi-Fi USB Connector.
3. Catching: You can then encounter and catch these transferred Pokémon in the Pal Park.
Note: This method only allows you to transfer Pokémon from Emerald to Pearl. It's not possible to transfer Pokémon from Pearl to Emerald or play Emerald on your DS using a Pearl save file.