Would Lily's Protection Charm Shield Lucius from Dobby?
This is unanswerable canonically—J.K. Rowling never defined the charm's limits against non-Voldemort magic. Analysis:
Arguments for Protection
- The charm deflected Voldemort's Killing Curse (the ultimate dark magic). Dobby's magic (house-elf magic) is powerful but not inherently lethal.
- It protected Harry from Quirrell (possessed by Voldemort) and in the graveyard (Priori Incantatem).
Arguments Against
- The charm was specifically anchored to Voldemort ("while you can still call home the place where your mother's blood dwells"). It may not trigger against a house-elf's non-lethal restraint.
- Dobby's intent was protective (stopping Harry from returning to the Dursleys), not murderous. The charm responds to deadly intent.
- House-elf magic operates outside wizard laws (Apparating in Hogwarts, etc.); it might bypass the charm entirely.
Most Likely Outcome
The charm would probably not activate because Dobby wasn't trying to kill Harry. If it did, it might simply deflect the spell harmlessly—Lucius would be unharmed either way, as he wasn't the caster.