Arts >> Magic >> Magic Shows

Would Lily's Protection Charm Shield Lucius from Dobby?

This is unanswerable canonically—J.K. Rowling never defined the charm's limits against non-Voldemort magic. Analysis:

Arguments for Protection

Arguments Against

Most Likely Outcome

The charm would probably not activate because Dobby wasn't trying to kill Harry. If it did, it might simply deflect the spell harmlessly—Lucius would be unharmed either way, as he wasn't the caster.

Magic Shows

Related Categories