Doctrine of Supervening Impossibility in Contract Law
When Contracts Become Impossible to Perform
Supervening impossibility occurs when a contract becomes objectively impossible to perform due to unforeseen events beyond either party's control. When this happens, the contract is discharged, and both parties are released from their obligations.
Required Conditions
- Objective impossibility: No one could perform, not just the obligated party.
- Total impossibility: The entire contract cannot be performed, not just a part.
- Post-formation occurrence: The event must happen after the contract is formed. If it existed beforehand, it's a mistake rendering the contract voidable.
Examples
- A house sold is destroyed by fire before closing.
- Goods to be transported are lost at sea.
- An entertainer becomes ill before a performance.
Consequences
- Parties are released from obligations.
- Money paid must be refunded.
- Neither party can claim damages from the other.
Exceptions
- Force Majeure Clause: Many contracts include this to allocate risk for supervening events.
- Impracticability: In some jurisdictions, extreme and unreasonable difficulty (not strict impossibility) may also discharge a contract.
Courts examine the specific facts of each case to determine if the doctrine applies.