The quote references The Adventure of the Speckled Band. Holmes publicly condemns Dr. Roylott's abuse of his stepdaughter Julia, yet Roylott maintains a respectable public façade. Alone, Holmes reviews the evidence—a poisonous snake, a locked room, a ventilator—and deduces Roylott murdered Julia. The contrast is stark: public performance versus private deduction. Holmes sees through the veneer of respectability to the murderous truth beneath.