Starting a New Game in Pokémon HeartGold Erases Your Pokémon
Yes. A new game creates a fresh save file; your previous Pokémon are gone because:
- Save data is separate per file.
- No in-game transfer between save files exists.
- Trading requires a second DS and another copy of HeartGold/SoulSilver.
To keep your Pokémon:
- Continue your current save.
- Or start a new game on a different save slot (if available)—your original file remains intact.