Yu‑Gi‑Oh! Ruling: “Return 2 Opponent’s + 1 Your Monster” When Opponent Has Only 1 Monster
The effect resolves fully for your monsters; the opponent’s single monster is returned, and the second “opponent’s monster” target simply fails to resolve (no additional penalty).
Step‑by‑Step Resolution
- Activation: You declare the effect (e.g., Compulsory Evacuation Device ×2 + Penguin Soldier, or a single card like Phoenix Wing Wind Blast targeting multiple).
- Target selection: You choose up to two opponent’s monsters and one of your own. If the opponent controls only one monster, you target that one.
- Chain resolution: Effects resolve backward. The targeted monsters are returned to their owners’ hands simultaneously.
- Missing target: The “second opponent’s monster” target has no legal object. That part of the effect does nothing—it does not force you to target your own monster instead, nor does it fizzle the entire effect.
Key Rule: “As Much As Possible”
Yu‑Gi‑Oh follows the principle: do as much of the effect as possible. Valid targets are processed; invalid/missing targets are ignored. The rest of the effect (returning your monster) still happens.
Example Cards With Similar Multi‑Target Returns
- Penguin Soldier (FLIP: Target up to 2 monsters on field; return to hand)
- Giant Trunade (Returns all Spells/Traps—no targeting, so field count irrelevant)
- Brionac, Dragon of the Ice Barrier (Discard to target any cards; same “up to” logic)
Bottom line: Your card works normally. Opponent’s lone monster bounces; your chosen monster bounces; game moves on.