Can You Start a New Game in Pokémon Black While Keeping Your Old Save? No, One Save File Only
No. The DS cartridge holds only one save file. Starting a new game overwrites the old one permanently.
Workarounds
- Second cartridge: Buy another copy; keep one save per cart.
- Trade to a friend: Move Pokémon to their game, restart yours, trade back later.
- Emulation: Play on PC via emulator (allows multiple save files). Legal warning: Downloading ROMs/emulators may violate copyright in your region.