HeartGold vs. SoulSilver: Which Is Better? Differences and Shared Features
Both are excellent remakes of Gold/Silver. Differences:
HeartGold
- Based on Gold Version (Ho-Oh at Lv.40, Lugia at Lv.70).
- Slightly darker tone.
- Female protagonist (Kris/Lyra) from Gold.
- Starter follows you in overworld.
SoulSilver
- Based on Silver Version (Lugia at Lv.40, Ho-Oh at Lv.70).
- Brighter tone.
- Male protagonist (Ethan) from Silver.
Shared
- Identical mechanics, graphics, Pokéwalker support, post-game.
Choose HeartGold for Ho-Oh early/darker story; SoulSilver for Lugia early/brighter story. Otherwise, identical quality.