Arts >> Dance >> Waltz

Why Jing-mei's Mother Pushes Piano in "Two Kinds" — The Ed Sullivan Show, Not "Juilliard Ju"

In Amy Tan's "Two Kinds" (from The Joy Luck Club), Jing-mei's mother is inspired after seeing a young Chinese girl perform piano on The Ed Sullivan Show—not reading about "Juilliard Ju" (a common misremembering).

The Catalyst

The girl was likely a prodigy showcase (common on variety shows then). Jing-mei's mother, an immigrant with high hopes for her daughter's American success, decides: piano = prestige, discipline, assimilation. She trades housecleaning services for lessons with Mr. Chong, a deaf retired teacher.

The Clash

Mother's transferential ambition vs. daughter's resistance to being molded. The talent show disaster ("Pleading Child") cements the rift. Decades later, Jing-mei plays "Perfectly Contented"—the companion piece—realizing they're two halves of one song.

Core Theme

The story isn't about piano. It's about immigrant motherhood as projection—the child as vessel for unfulfilled dreams. And the daughter's reclaiming of agency through the very instrument of oppression.

Waltz

Related Categories