The song's title, "What a Catch, Donnie," is sarcastic and ironic. It suggests that Donnie is seen as a desirable and successful man, but the song itself reveals his true character as someone who is selfish and manipulative.
Throughout the song, Donnie is described as someone who is "smooth-talking" and "slick," and who uses his charm to get what he wants. He "never misses a shot" when it comes to wooing women, and he is seen as a "ladies' man" who has no trouble attracting attention. However, the lyrics also reveal that Donnie is not interested in forming genuine connections or relationships. He is only interested in using women for his own pleasure and satisfaction, and he shows no regard for their feelings.
The song also suggests that Donnie's behavior is not just harmful to the individuals he targets but also to himself. He is depicted as someone who is "losing control" and "falling apart," and the lyrics imply that his actions are ultimately unsustainable and will eventually lead to his downfall.
Overall, "What a Catch, Donnie" is a satirical commentary on the negative aspects of toxic masculinity and the culture of objectification in dating. Through the character of Donnie, the song warns against the dangers of using charm and manipulation to take advantage of others and encourages people to seek genuine and meaningful connections in their relationships.