Why Mothballs Sink in Baking Soda–Vinegar (And How to Make Them Dance)
They sink because they’re denser than the reaction mixture.
Density Facts
- Water: 1.00 g/mL
- Vinegar (5% acetic acid): ~1.01 g/mL
- Baking soda (solid): 2.16 g/mL
- Mothballs (naphthalene/paradichlorobenzene): ~1.15–1.30 g/mL
Mixture density ≈ 1.0–1.1 g/mL → mothballs sink.
The “Dancing Mothballs” Trick (Correct Version)
Use baking soda + water (NO vinegar) + mothballs.
- Dissolve 2–3 tablespoons baking soda in 1 cup warm water (saturate the solution).
- Drop in mothballs.
- They sink, then rise, sink, rise—“dance.”
Why It Works
- CO₂ bubbles nucleate on the rough mothball surface.
- Buoyancy lifts the mothball → bubbles burst at surface → mothball sinks → repeat.
- Reaction: NaHCO₃ + H⁺ (from carbonic acid equilibrium) → CO₂↑. Slow, sustained.
Why the Vinegar Version Fails
- Rapid, violent reaction—bubbles too large, mothballs just tumble.
- Acid may degrade naphthalene.
Correct demo: Saturated baking soda water + mothballs = slow, rhythmic dancing.