Contrary to the premise, clog dancers do not hold their arms straight down as a fixed rule. Arm movement is integral to the style:
Early folk collectors sometimes described dancers as "arms motionless" to emphasize intricate footwork. Static arms in performance photos (exposure limitations) reinforced the image. In reality, relaxed, natural upper-body movement aids rhythm, balance, and expression.
Clogging prioritizes percussive footwork; arms serve the dance, not a rigid aesthetic. Styles vary regionally and individually.