Neither was objectively "better"—they pursued different designs:
Pros: Precise motion controls (wand + camera), larger dedicated game library (including The Last of Us and Uncharted 3 support), cheaper.
Cons: Limited tracking range, no full-body tracking, requires multiple peripherals.
Pros: Full-body, controller-free tracking; accessible for casual/family play; innovative non-gaming apps (fitness, UI navigation).
Cons: Less precise for core games, smaller dedicated library, higher launch price.
Preference depended on whether you valued accuracy or controller-free freedom.