Season 1 (2005): Nick Lazzarini and Melody Lacayanga
Season 2 (2006): Benji Schwimmer and Travis Wall
Season 3 (2007): Sabra Johnson and Dominic Sandoval
Season 4 (2008): Joshua Allen and Stephen "tWitch" Boss
Season 5 (2009): Jeanine Mason and Jason Glover
Season 6 (2010): Russell Ferguson and Anya Garnis
Season 7 (2011): Lauren Froderman and Kent Boyd
Season 8 (2012): Melanie Moore and Marko Germar
Season 9 (2013): Eliana Girard and Chehon Wespi-Tschopp
Season 10 (2014): Amy Yakima and Fik-Shun Stegall
Season 11 (2015): Ricky Ubeda and Valerie Rockey
Season 12 (2016): Gaby Diaz and Jake Monreal
Season 13 (2017): Kida The Great and Emma Slater
Season 14 (2018): Lex Ishimoto and Eliana Girard
Season 15 (2019): Hannahlei Cabanilla and Jake Humphrey
Season 16 (2020): Bailey Muñoz and Alexis Warr