The Doctor Never Saw Lady Macbeth Sleepwalk—The Gentlewoman Did
Correction: The doctor never personally witnesses Lady Macbeth sleepwalking until the second night of scheduled observation—and the gentlewoman is the primary witness.
Actual Sequence (Act 5, Scene 1)
- Gentlewoman (Lady Macbeth's attendant) reports sleepwalking to the doctor
- Doctor agrees to watch with her for two nights
- Night 1: Nothing observed
- Night 2: Lady Macbeth enters sleepwalking — gentlewoman and doctor both witness
Why the Distinction Matters
- Not "how many nights did the doctor wait"
- Rather: Two nights of scheduled observation; sleepwalking occurs on the second
- Gentlewoman is primary witness; doctor confirms
Dramatic Significance
The doctor's clinical helplessness — "This disease is beyond my practice" — contrasts with the gentlewoman's intimate knowledge. Male medical authority fails; female domestic observation succeeds.
Shakespeare gives the truth-teller role to the servant, not the expert. The gentlewoman knows; the doctor diagnoses. Guess which matters more.