Reverend Hale's journey in Arthur Miller's The Crucible is often misunderstood. He does not initially believe Abigail over Tituba. In Act 1, he pressures Tituba into a coerced confession; Abigail then joins the accusations. Hale's faith in the proceedings erodes only when John Proctor exposes Abigail's motive—her affair with Proctor and vengeful intent—in Act 3. By Act 4, Hale denounces the court entirely, urging false confessions to save lives. He never fully "believes" Abigail; he is manipulated, then awakens to the fraud.