The lyrics use multiple poetic and complex words and imagery, which has allowed listeners to find numerous interpretations in it. Some people find that the song has religious undertones because it speaks of a young man lost in a world that seems chaotic and full of hypocrisy. The lyrics mention a time of "confusion" and "disillusionment," which some interpret as a reference to a spiritual crisis or journey. The line "Where have you gone, Joe DiMaggio?" has also been interpreted as a metaphor for the loss of religious faith or innocence in the face of modern society's challenges and temptations.
On the other hand, others perceive the song as a sort of mocking or cynical view of religion, with the lines referring to Mrs. Robinson as a "jewel" who is "so easy to please" and "she calls me honey," suggesting a playful or insincere relationship. The "pee-ka-boo" reference adds to this mischievous tone.
Ultimately, the meaning of Mrs Robinson and the interpretation of its religious aspects are subjective and may differ from person to person. The song's ambiguous and symbolic lyrics allow each listener to find their own significance in it.