The Baconian Theory: Francis Bacon as Shakespeare? The Evidence and the Gaps
Since the 19th century, the “Baconian theory” has argued that Sir Francis Bacon—philosopher, scientist, statesman—authored the Shakespeare canon.
The Case For
- Bacon’s elite education (Cambridge, Gray’s Inn) matches the plays’ legal, classical, and scientific erudition.
- His known interests—law, cryptography, natural philosophy, politics—mirror the plays’ preoccupations.
- Stylometric parallels: vocabulary range, rhetorical devices, rare word usage.
- Bacon’s “Promus” (commonplace book) contains phrases later appearing in Shakespeare.
The Case Against
- No contemporary attributed the plays to Bacon.
- Bacon never claimed them, even in private writings.
- Social status: Bacon was a peer; Shakespeare a player. The class gap is immense.
- Political views: Bacon was a monarchist/establishment figure; the plays often subvert authority.
- Dating: Many plays post-date Bacon’s death (1626) or align with Shakespeare’s life events.
Verdict
The debate persists because both men were geniuses of language. But the documentary trail—title pages, stationers’ records, Ben Jonson’s testimony, the First Folio dedication—points to William Shakespeare of Stratford. Bacon’s impact is real; his authorship is not.