Issue: Whether religious polygamy is protected by the First Amendment’s Free Exercise Clause.
Background: Two Mormon families (Hill and Waxberg) were convicted under federal anti‑bigamy laws in Utah Territory. They claimed a religious exemption.
Holding (6‑3): The Court ruled that the Free Exercise Clause does not exempt individuals from generally applicable criminal laws. The state’s interest in social order and preventing harm justifies banning polygamy.
Significance: Established that neutral, generally applicable laws trump religious practice claims—a precedent later refined in Employment Division v. Smith (1990).