Nine Logical Fallacies in Arthur Miller's The Crucible
The Crucible is a masterclass in the fallacies that drive witch hunts—both 1692 and 1950s. Nine formal and informal fallacies structure the Salem court's "logic":
- Ad Hominem: Abigail attacks Proctor's character (lechery) instead of addressing the witchcraft charge.
- Circular Reasoning: Danforth: Witches must confess because they're guilty; they're guilty because they confessed.
- Equivocation: Abigail uses ambiguous language ("I saw Sarah Good with the Devil!") to evade precise accountability.
- Appeal to Authority: The court defers to Parris's and Putnam's status despite their obvious bias and lack of evidence.
- Slippery Slope: Parris warns that unpunished witchcraft will destroy the community—catastrophic consequences without proof.
- Guilt by Association: Accusations spread through social networks—knowing an accused makes you suspect.
- Obfuscation: The court avoids direct questions (e.g., "Why does the girl faint only when accused?") to maintain the illusion of justice.
- Bandwagon Fallacy: Townspeople join accusations from fear and social pressure, not conviction.
- Red Herring: Mary Warren's fainting fits divert attention from Abigail's deception.
Miller didn't just depict fallacies—he weaponized them dramatically. The play is a taxonomy of corrupted reason.