Arts >> Books >> Literature

The "Second" or "Old Description" of Romeo and Juliet: Arthur Brooke's 1562 Poem

The "Old Description" refers to Arthur Brooke's narrative poem The Tragicall Historye of Romeus and Juliet (1562) — Shakespeare's primary source.

Brooke's Version vs. Shakespeare's Play

ElementBrooke (1562)Shakespeare (c. 1595)
Form3,020 lines of poulter's measure (12/14 syllable couplets)Blank verse + prose + sonnet forms; ~3,000 lines drama
ToneDidactic, moralizing: "example of unstable youth"Tragic, empathetic; lovers as victims of fate/society
TimeframeMonths<4 days (compressed for intensity)
NurseMinor, comicMajor, complex, betrays Juliet
MercutioBarely mentionedVital, invented character (from hint in source)
Friar LawrenceConventional confessorPharmacist, schemer, flawed idealist
EndingRomeus dies by poison; Juliet stabs herselfSame, but with Paris killed, families reconciled onstage
Moral"Unlawful love leads to ruin""Love transcends hate; hate destroys love"

Other Sources Shakespeare Used

Why "Second Description"?

Brooke's poem was the immediate English source ("second" after Bandello/Da Porto in Italian). Shakespeare transformed a moralistic verse narrative into a dramatic masterpiece by adding psychological depth, comic relief, structural compression, and poetic density.

Literature

Related Categories