Spoonbridge and Cherry: Minneapolis's Controversial Icon
Claes Oldenburg and Coosje van Bruggen's Spoonbridge and Cherry (1988) sits in the Minneapolis Sculpture Garden like a surrealist picnic leftover: a 51-foot stainless steel spoon cradling a 16-foot bright red cherry, water streaming from the cherry's stem into a pond below. It's playful, massive, and utterly unignorable.
Why It's Celebrated
- Pop art at architectural scale – Transforms a domestic object into public monument, democratizing art.
- Site-specific genius – The spoon's bowl aligns with the garden's lattice; the cherry's reflection doubles the sculpture in water.
- Cultural ubiquity – Postcards, tourism campaigns, marriage proposals, snow-day sledding on the spoon's bowl (unofficially). It's Minneapolis's Eiffel Tower.
- Art historical weight – Oldenburg's large-scale ordinary objects (Clothespin, Batcolumn, Shuttlecocks) redefined public sculpture. This is a career peak.
Why It's Criticized
- Skyline obstruction – From certain angles, the cherry blocks the Walker Art Center's view corridor.
- "Kitsch" accusation – Critics argue it's a visual pun stretched thin: a spoon? A cherry? Really?
- Location disputes – Some wanted it downtown, not in a garden already dense with sculpture.
- Maintenance costs – Stainless steel requires specialized cleaning; the water system needs winterization.
The Verdict
Controversy is the point. Public art that pleases everyone challenges no one. Spoonbridge and Cherry forces a confrontation: What belongs in civic space? Who decides? Can a joke be a landmark? Three decades later, the answer is yes—Minneapolis wouldn't be Minneapolis without it.