The question is central to the tragedy. Friar Laurence advises patience and secrecy, hoping to reconcile the Montagues and Capulets before revealing the marriage. His plan requires restraint — qualities the impulsive, passionate lovers lack. Their decision to rush into marriage, and later Romeo's refusal to wait for the Friar's letter, leads directly to their deaths.
Critics argue that had they confided in the Friar about Juliet's feigned death, the fatal miscommunication could have been avoided. Yet the play also suggests that in a world governed by feud and fate, even wisdom may not prevail. Their choice to follow their hearts rather than the Friar's counsel underscores the theme of youthful passion versus reasoned counsel.
Ultimately, the tragedy arises from a collision of human impetuosity and unfortunate timing. Whether they should have followed his advice remains a matter of interpretation, but the play shows that ignoring it had fatal consequences.