Arts >> Books >> Literature

The Annotated Shakespeare: Authorship, History, and Collector Value

Setting the Record Straight

A persistent bibliographic error attributes The Annotated Shakespeare to the historian A.L. Rowse. In fact, the seminal work was authored by the literary critic A.C. Bradley and first published in 1894. Rowse wrote extensively on Shakespeare (notably Shakespeare the Man), but he was not the editor of this specific annotated edition.

Bradley's Landmark Edition

A.C. Bradley, Professor of Poetry at Oxford, brought his lecture-hall authority to the page. His edition focused on the major tragedies—Hamlet, Othello, King Lear, Macbeth—offering close readings that shaped generations of Shakespearean scholarship. Bradley’s approach was character-centric and psychological, treating the plays as windows into the human soul rather than merely historical documents.

Market Status and Valuation

The original 1894 edition (often published in multiple volumes by Macmillan) is long out of print. In the antiquarian book market, a complete set in good to fine condition** (original cloth, minimal foxing, intact hinges) commands prices around $2,000 USD. Factors increasing value include:

Later reprints (e.g., 1900s, 1960s Meridian paperbacks) are common and valued at $15–$50.

Why the Confusion Persists

The misattribution likely stems from Rowse's high profile in mid-20th-century Shakespeare studies and his own annotated edition of the Sonnets (1977). Booksellers and cataloguers occasionally conflate the two "Annotated" titles. Collectors should verify the author field: Bradley, A.C. (Andrew Cecil), 1851–1935.

Literature

Related Categories