Herman Melville, Edgar Allan Poe, and Nathaniel Hawthorne are classified as Dark Romantics (or American Gothic)—a sub-movement that shares Romanticism's focus on emotion, imagination, and the individual but diverges sharply in vision.
| Romanticism | Dark Romanticism |
|---|---|
| Nature as benevolent, sublime | Nature as indifferent or menacing |
| Optimism, perfectibility | Original sin, human fallibility |
| Intuition over reason | Intuition reveals darkness |
| Individual vs. society | Individual vs. self (guilt, madness) |
They are Romantics in period and technique, but their vision is distinctly pessimistic—hence "Dark."