Arts >> Books >> Literature

Melville, Poe, and Hawthorne: Dark Romantics, Not Pure Romantics

Herman Melville, Edgar Allan Poe, and Nathaniel Hawthorne are classified as Dark Romantics (or American Gothic)—a sub-movement that shares Romanticism's focus on emotion, imagination, and the individual but diverges sharply in vision.

RomanticismDark Romanticism
Nature as benevolent, sublimeNature as indifferent or menacing
Optimism, perfectibilityOriginal sin, human fallibility
Intuition over reasonIntuition reveals darkness
Individual vs. societyIndividual vs. self (guilt, madness)

Key Works

They are Romantics in period and technique, but their vision is distinctly pessimistic—hence "Dark."

Literature

Related Categories