Treatment of Protestants in Elizabethan England: Official Tolerance with Limits
Protestants in Elizabethan England (1558–1603) experienced official tolerance but with significant limits and internal tensions.
Official Policy: The Elizabethan Settlement (1559)
- Act of Supremacy: Elizabeth = Supreme Governor of Church of England.
- Act of Uniformity: Book of Common Prayer mandatory; attendance fined (12d/Sunday).
- Via Media: Moderate Protestantism—Catholic structure, Protestant theology.
Protestant Experience by Group
| Group | Treatment |
| Conforming Anglicans | Full citizenship; eligible for office, education, preferment. |
| Puritans (Presbyterians, Congregationalists) | Tolerated but pressured; nonconformity = fines, imprisonment, exile (e.g., Pilgrims to Holland 1608). |
| Separatists / Brownists | Persecuted; leaders executed (Barrow, Greenwood 1593); fled to Netherlands. |
| Catholics (Recusants) | Severely penalized: fines, property seizure, priest execution (1585 Act), Jesuit expulsion. |
Key Dynamics
- Marian Exiles return: 800+ Protestants fled Mary I; many became bishops/leaders.
- Admonition Controversy (1572): Puritan manifesto → crackdown.
- Martin Marprelate Tracts (1588-89): Satirical Puritan pamphlets → harsh suppression.
- Regional variation: London/SE = Puritan stronghold; North/West = more Catholic.
- Social class: Gentry/merchant Puritans protected by patrons; poor more vulnerable.
Outcome
Church of England entrenched; Puritanism driven underground → later Civil War fuel. "Protestant" meant Anglican by law; dissenters = "Nonconformists."