Arts >> Books >> Fiction

Does the Narrator Keep a Promise to Sam McGee? Not in the Poem.

Robert Service's "The Cremation of Sam McGee" (1907) contains no promise by the narrator to Sam McGee. The poem's premise: Sam, freezing on the Yukon trail, makes the narrator promise to cremate his body. The narrator fulfills this grim vow—burning Sam in the boiler of the Alice May—and Sam's ghost pops out, warm and cheerful.

The question appears to misattribute the promise. The narrator keeps Sam's request; Sam makes no promise to the narrator.

Service's ballad is a masterpiece of macabre humor and Yukon atmosphere—not a story of mutual pledges.

Fiction

Related Categories