Carol Gilligan's Research on Moral Development: The Ethics of Care vs. Justice
Carol Gilligan's landmark work (In a Different Voice, 1982) challenged Lawrence Kohlberg's male-centric stage theory of moral reasoning. Key contributions:
1. Gender Bias in Kohlberg's Model
Kohlberg's stages (pre-conventional → conventional → post-conventional) were derived from studies of boys/men. Women often scored "lower" (stage 3: interpersonal concordance) because the model privileged abstract justice (stage 5–6) over relational care.
2. The "Different Voice" — Ethics of Care
- Justice Perspective (Kohlberg): Rights, rules, impartiality, universal principles.
- Care Perspective (Gilligan): Responsibility, relationships, context, responsiveness to need, avoidance of harm.
Women (and many men) tend to frame moral dilemmas as problems of connection rather than contract.
3. Three Levels of Care Reasoning
- Selfish → Survival, self-interest.
- Conventional Care → Self-sacrifice, goodness as meeting others' expectations.
- Integrated Care → Mutual responsibility; self and others valued equally; context-sensitive judgment.
4. Critique & Legacy
- Critics note: small samples, essentialism risk, cultural variability.
- Impact: transformed feminist ethics, psychology, education (care-based pedagogy), nursing, conflict resolution, and organizational leadership.
- Expanded moral theory beyond "justice as fairness" to include "care as responsiveness."
Gilligan didn't claim women are more caring — she argued that care reasoning is a legitimate, developable moral framework marginalized by androcentric theory.