Arts >> Books >> Fiction

What important fact does Atticus bring out in his cross examination of bob Ewell?

During his cross-examination of Bob Ewell, Atticus Finch exposes several crucial contradictions and inconsistencies in Ewell's testimony, which casts significant doubt on his credibility and the veracity of his accusations against Tom Robinson. Here are the important facts that Atticus brings out:

1. Attempted Assault on Mayella:

- Atticus reveals that Ewell is left-handed, contradicting Mayella's statement that Tom, a black man, attacked her with his "left" hand.

- By demonstrating Mayella's ability to use her left hand efficiently, Atticus implies that she could have inflicted the injuries on herself.

2. Inaccurate Description of Tom's Assault:

- Atticus points out that Mayella's initial statement mentioned a "raping," but subsequent statements and Ewell's testimony change to "kissing" and "hugging."

- By highlighting these inconsistencies, Atticus raises questions about the true nature and gravity of the alleged assault.

3. Ewell's Drunkenness:

- Atticus reveals that Ewell was drinking heavily on the day of the incident and was often known to be violent and abusive towards his own children.

- This information shows that Ewell may have been intoxicated at the time of the alleged assault, potentially compromising his memory and judgment.

4. Ewell's Threats:

- Atticus presents evidence of Ewell's threats to kill Tom Robinson and his attempts to get Helen Robinson, Tom's wife, fired from her job.

- By establishing a pattern of hostility and vindictiveness, Atticus suggests that Ewell's accusations may be motivated by personal animosity rather than genuine victimization.

5. Lack of Corroborating Evidence:

- Atticus emphasizes the absence of any independent witnesses or physical evidence to support Ewell's claims.

- By highlighting this lack of corroboration, Atticus undermines Ewell's credibility and raises doubts about the reliability of his testimony.

Overall, through his skillful cross-examination, Atticus exposes Bob Ewell's inconsistencies, suggests alternative explanations for the events in question, and raises serious doubts about Ewell's motives and reliability as a witness. This directly challenges the prosecution's case and further strengthens Tom Robinson's defense.

Fiction

Related Categories