Why Watson Narrates The Hound of the Baskervilles: Benefits and Drawbacks
Arthur Conan Doyle chose Dr. John Watson—not Sherlock Holmes—to narrate The Hound of the Baskervilles. The decision shapes everything we feel reading it.
Benefits
- Relatability: Watson is ordinary—intelligent but not superhuman. Readers share his puzzlement, fear, and awe.
- Suspense: Mystery unfolds through Watson's limited view. We discover clues when he does.
- Humor and warmth: Watson's affection for Holmes, his exasperation, his domestic observations lighten the gothic gloom.
- Character depth: We see Holmes through loving but clear eyes—brilliant, eccentric, occasionally cruel, deeply human.
Drawbacks
- Limited perspective: We only know what Watson sees/understands. Holmes's silent deductions remain opaque until explained.
- Potential misdirection: Watson occasionally misreads clues, leading readers astray.
- No direct access to Holmes's mind: The "aha!" moments are reported, not experienced.
Verdict
The benefits outweigh the costs. Watson's narration makes the supernatural plausible, the friendship tangible, and the mystery solvable with the reader—not just for the reader. It's the perfect lens for this particular story.