Why Lily and James Potter Didn't Become Their Own Secret Keeper
They did not. The role went to Peter Pettigrew, their close friend.
Why They Declined
- Risk of Compromise: As Secret Keepers, they'd be sole targets for Voldemort. Killing them would reveal the secret.
- Vulnerability: Capture or torture would force the secret out.
They trusted Pettigrew—a fatal miscalculation that led to their deaths and Harry's survival as the Boy Who Lived.