Movie About a Mother Forced to Choose Between Children: Sophie's Choice (1982)
You're describing Sophie's Choice (1982), directed by Alan J. Pakula, starring Meryl Streep in an Oscar-winning performance.
Key Details
- Character: Sophie Zawistowska (Polish Catholic, not Jewish—Auschwitz imprisoned Poles too).
- The Choice: Upon arrival at Auschwitz, an SS doctor forces her: "Which one lives? The boy or the girl?" She screams "Take my little girl!"—son Jan sent to labor camp, daughter Eva to the gas chamber.
- Aftermath: Guilt destroys her postwar life (NYC, 1947); suicide with lover Nathan.
- Source: William Styron's 1979 novel.
Why Not Son of Saul (2015)?
Son of Saul follows a male Sonderkommando (Saul Ausländer) seeking a rabbi for a boy he claims is his son. No mother, no choice scene. Different film entirely.
Other Holocaust "Choice" Films
- The Pawnbroker (1964) — survivor guilt, not a choice scene.
- Life Is Beautiful (1997) — father shields son via game-frame.
- Schindler's List (1993) — Kindertransport, list-making.
Definitive answer: Sophie's Choice—the iconic "choose your child" moment.