Brian Wilson's therapist, Dr. Eugene Landy, prompted the breakthrough. During a session, Landy asked Brian to express love for his wife Marilyn at the piano. Brian played a chord progression and sang "I may not always love you..." – the song's opening.
At session's end, Brian exclaimed, "God only knows" – realizing the phrase captured the terrifying vulnerability of total devotion. Landy replied, "That's the title."
Collaborator Tony Asher shaped the lyrics; Carl Wilson sang lead. The result: a harmonic masterpiece (key changes, unusual chords) expressing love as a leap of faith.
Landy's controversial later role shouldn't overshadow this genuine therapeutic moment that birthed a classic.