Nancy Farmer's dystopian novel portrays a world where cloning for organ harvest is normalized. The protagonist, Matt, is a clone of a drug lord, raised for spare parts. A striking implausibility is the near-total absence of societal resistance—no mass protests, ethical debates, or legal challenges. This complacency strains credibility given real-world bioethical controversies. Additionally, several characters' motivations remain opaque, leaving narrative gaps. The novel excels in premise and atmosphere but underexplores the moral friction its world should generate.