The source material provides no information linking “American intellectuals” as a group to Elizabeth Proctor, the historical figure from Arthur Miller’s The Crucible (and the 1692 Salem witch trials). Without a specific text, movement, or historical framework that connects them, any comparison would be speculative and unfounded.
Elizabeth Proctor was a 17th-century Salem woman—practical, morally rigid, and deeply wounded by her husband’s adultery. “American intellectuals” is an impossibly broad category spanning centuries and ideologies. The two share no inherent analytical relationship.