Who is the best grandmother from two grandmothers ( justify ) by olive senior?

Olive Senior's story Two Grandmothers presents two contrasting characters, Ma Ivy and Miss Mary, who embody different aspects of grandmotherhood. While both women are loving and supportive of their grandchildren, their individual qualities and approaches to life set them apart.

Ma Ivy represents a traditional, rural Jamaican grandmother. She is described as "a small woman with a round face and a broad smile" and is known for her herbal remedies and storytelling abilities. Ma Ivy is deeply rooted in her community and embraces traditional practices. She is a skilled healer who uses natural remedies to cure illnesses, and her wisdom and knowledge of local folklore endear her to the children in the village.

Miss Mary, on the other hand, is an educated, urban grandmother who lives in Kingston. She is described as "a tall, thin woman with a stern face" and is known for her love of books and her insistence on proper etiquette. Miss Mary values education and social status, and she strives to instill these values in her grandchildren. She encourages them to read and strive for academic success, and she is quick to correct any deviation from proper manners.

Comparing these two grandmothers, it is evident that both play important roles in the lives of their grandchildren. Ma Ivy provides a sense of belonging, tradition, and cultural heritage. She nurtures her grandchildren's connection to their roots and teaches them valuable life lessons through her stories and experiences. Miss Mary, on the other hand, emphasizes the importance of education, discipline, and social refinement. She prepares her grandchildren for success in an increasingly competitive world by fostering intellectual growth and social awareness.

Ultimately, the best grandmother is a matter of personal preference and depends on the individual's needs and desires. Ma Ivy's warmth, traditional wisdom, and nurturing approach may resonate with those seeking a close, familial connection and a strong sense of identity. Miss Mary's intellectual rigor, insistence on proper etiquette, and focus on personal growth may appeal to those valuing academic achievement and social success. Both grandmothers offer valuable lessons and guidance, and their contrasting qualities highlight the diverse roles that grandmothers can play in enriching the lives of their grandchildren.