Ch. 1–3: Winnie Foster (10) meets the Tucks—Mae, Angus, Miles, Jesse—who drank from a spring granting immortality 87 years ago. She learns their secret.
Ch. 4–6: The Man in the Yellow Suit (antagonist) seeks the spring to sell its water. He steals the Tucks' horse; Winnie is taken to their hidden cabin.
Ch. 7–10: Winnie bonds with Jesse; Angus explains the burden of eternal life. The Man in the Yellow Suit tracks them.
Ch. 11–15: Tucks flee; Winnie helps Mae escape jail after she kills the Man to protect Winnie. Winnie chooses not to drink the water.
Ch. 16–20: Winnie returns home, changed. The Tucks leave. Decades later, they return to find her grave—she lived a mortal life.
Ch. 21–25: Epilogue: Tucks see Winnie's headstone (1870–1948). Angus salutes her choice. The spring is bulldozed; the cycle ends.
Core theme: Mortality gives life meaning; immortality is stagnation.